fix: address round 2 review findings from issue #81

- Move atomic mv inside gardener loop so reply is only claimed when a
  matching needs_human session exists (fixes reply-loss regression)
- Delay rm of claimed file until after successful injection in both
  supervisor and gardener (OOM/SIGKILL leaves file recoverable)
- Fix matrix_listener ack message: 'next poll' instead of 'next supervisor poll'

Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.6 <noreply@anthropic.com>

gardener/gardener-poll.sh

@@ -66,23 +66,24 @@ fi
 
 # ── Inject human replies into needs_human dev sessions (backup to supervisor) ─
 HUMAN_REPLY_FILE="/tmp/dev-escalation-reply"
-_gr_claimed="/tmp/dev-escalation-reply.gardener.$$"
+for _gr_phase_file in /tmp/dev-session-"${PROJECT_NAME}"-*.phase; do
-if [ -s "$HUMAN_REPLY_FILE" ] && mv "$HUMAN_REPLY_FILE" "$_gr_claimed" 2>/dev/null; then
+  [ -f "$_gr_phase_file" ] || continue
+  _gr_phase=$(head -1 "$_gr_phase_file" 2>/dev/null | tr -d '[:space:]' || true)
+  [ "$_gr_phase" = "PHASE:needs_human" ] || continue
+
+  _gr_issue=$(basename "$_gr_phase_file" .phase)
+  _gr_issue="${_gr_issue#dev-session-${PROJECT_NAME}-}"
+  [ -z "$_gr_issue" ] && continue
+  _gr_session="dev-${PROJECT_NAME}-${_gr_issue}"
+
+  tmux has-session -t "$_gr_session" 2>/dev/null || continue
+
+  # Atomic claim — only take the file once we know a session needs it
+  _gr_claimed="/tmp/dev-escalation-reply.gardener.$$"
+  [ -s "$HUMAN_REPLY_FILE" ] && mv "$HUMAN_REPLY_FILE" "$_gr_claimed" 2>/dev/null || continue
   _gr_reply=$(cat "$_gr_claimed")
-  rm -f "$_gr_claimed"
-  for _gr_phase_file in /tmp/dev-session-"${PROJECT_NAME}"-*.phase; do
-    [ -f "$_gr_phase_file" ] || continue
-    _gr_phase=$(head -1 "$_gr_phase_file" 2>/dev/null | tr -d '[:space:]' || true)
-    [ "$_gr_phase" = "PHASE:needs_human" ] || continue
 
-    _gr_issue=$(basename "$_gr_phase_file" .phase)
+  _gr_inject_msg="Human reply received for issue #${_gr_issue}:
-    _gr_issue="${_gr_issue#dev-session-${PROJECT_NAME}-}"
-    [ -z "$_gr_issue" ] && continue
-    _gr_session="dev-${PROJECT_NAME}-${_gr_issue}"
-
-    tmux has-session -t "$_gr_session" 2>/dev/null || continue
-
-    _gr_inject_msg="Human reply received for issue #${_gr_issue}:
 
 ${_gr_reply}
 
@@ -91,20 +92,19 @@ Instructions:
 2. Continue your work based on their input.
 3. When done, push your changes and write the appropriate phase."
 
-    _gr_tmpfile=$(mktemp /tmp/human-inject-XXXXXX)
+  _gr_tmpfile=$(mktemp /tmp/human-inject-XXXXXX)
-    printf '%s' "$_gr_inject_msg" > "$_gr_tmpfile"
+  printf '%s' "$_gr_inject_msg" > "$_gr_tmpfile"
-    tmux load-buffer -b "human-inject-${_gr_issue}" "$_gr_tmpfile" || true
+  tmux load-buffer -b "human-inject-${_gr_issue}" "$_gr_tmpfile" || true
-    tmux paste-buffer -t "$_gr_session" -b "human-inject-${_gr_issue}" || true
+  tmux paste-buffer -t "$_gr_session" -b "human-inject-${_gr_issue}" || true
-    sleep 0.5
+  sleep 0.5
-    tmux send-keys -t "$_gr_session" "" Enter || true
+  tmux send-keys -t "$_gr_session" "" Enter || true
-    tmux delete-buffer -b "human-inject-${_gr_issue}" 2>/dev/null || true
+  tmux delete-buffer -b "human-inject-${_gr_issue}" 2>/dev/null || true
-    rm -f "$_gr_tmpfile"
+  rm -f "$_gr_tmpfile" "$_gr_claimed"
 
-    rm -f "/tmp/dev-renotify-${PROJECT_NAME}-${_gr_issue}"
+  rm -f "/tmp/dev-renotify-${PROJECT_NAME}-${_gr_issue}"
-    log "${PROJECT_NAME}: #${_gr_issue} human reply injected into session ${_gr_session} (gardener)"
+  log "${PROJECT_NAME}: #${_gr_issue} human reply injected into session ${_gr_session} (gardener)"
-    break  # only one reply to deliver
+  break  # only one reply to deliver
-  done
+done
-fi
 
 # ── Fetch all open issues ─────────────────────────────────────────────────
 ISSUES_JSON=$(codeberg_api GET "/issues?state=open&type=issues&limit=50&sort=updated&direction=desc" 2>/dev/null || true)

lib/matrix_listener.sh

@@ -143,7 +143,7 @@ while true; do
         ;;
       dev)
         printf '%s\t%s\t%s\n' "$(date -u +%Y-%m-%dT%H:%M:%SZ)" "$SENDER" "$BODY" >> /tmp/dev-escalation-reply
-        matrix_send "dev" "✓ received, will inject on next supervisor poll" "$THREAD_ROOT" >/dev/null 2>&1 || true
+        matrix_send "dev" "✓ received, will inject on next poll" "$THREAD_ROOT" >/dev/null 2>&1 || true
         ;;
       vault)
         # Parse APPROVE <id> or REJECT <id> from reply

supervisor/supervisor-poll.sh

@@ -540,7 +540,6 @@ check_project() {
     _nh_claimed="/tmp/dev-escalation-reply.supervisor.$$"
     if [ -s "$HUMAN_REPLY_FILE" ] && mv "$HUMAN_REPLY_FILE" "$_nh_claimed" 2>/dev/null; then
       _nh_reply=$(cat "$_nh_claimed")
-      rm -f "$_nh_claimed"
       _nh_inject_msg="Human reply received for issue #${_nh_issue}:
 
 ${_nh_reply}
@@ -558,7 +557,7 @@ Instructions:
       sleep 0.5
       tmux send-keys -t "$_nh_session" "" Enter || true
       tmux delete-buffer -b "human-inject-${_nh_issue}" 2>/dev/null || true
-      rm -f "$_nh_tmpfile"
+      rm -f "$_nh_tmpfile" "$_nh_claimed"
 
       rm -f "/tmp/dev-renotify-${proj_name}-${_nh_issue}"
       flog "${proj_name}: #${_nh_issue} human reply injected into session ${_nh_session}"