Merge pull request 'chore: planner run — prerequisite tree update' (#719) from chore/planner-20260326-0718 into main

planner/MEMORY.md

@@ -1,27 +1,45 @@
-<!-- summarized-through-run: 1 -->
+<!-- summarized-through-run: 6 -->
 # Planner Memory
 
-## 2026-03-21 — Second planner run
+## 2026-03-26 — Sixth planner run
 
 ### Milestone state
-- **Foundation**: COMPLETE. Agent loop, supervisor, planner, multi-project all working.
-- **Adoption**: IN PROGRESS. Bootstrap (#393), docs (#394), dashboard (#395), example project (#466) all in backlog. No work started yet — issues were unlabeled until this run fixed them.
-- **Scale**: PARTIALLY started (multi-project works for 3 repos).
+- **Foundation**: COMPLETE. All agent loops, supervisor, planner, multi-project, knowledge graph, predictor-planner feedback loop — all working.
+- **Adoption**: 4/5 COMPLETE. Bootstrap (#393), docs (#394), dashboard (#395), landing page (#534) all done. Only #466 (example project) remains — stuck on human decision since 2026-03-23.
+- **Ship (Fold 2)**: ENTERING SCOPE. Rent-a-human (#679) done. Exec agent (#699) done. Observable addressables (#718) filed. Deploy profiles and assumptions register not yet tracked.
+- **Scale**: DEFERRED. No external users yet. Plugin system, community formulas, hosted option all premature.
+
+### Completed since last summary (runs 2-6)
+- Bootstrap fully hardened: init smoke test (#668), CI wiring (#661), Forgejo reachability (#660), 10+ bootstrap fixes
+- Full stack containerized (#618, #619) with Forgejo, Woodpecker, Dendrite
+- Autonomous merge pipeline (#568) — PRs auto-merge on CI pass + approval
+- Unified escalation path (#510) — PHASE:escalate replaces needs_human
+- Factory operational reliability — guard logging (#663), stale phase cleanup (#664)
+- Prediction/backlog killed (#686) — planner now only ACTIONs or DISMISSes predictions
+- Planner v2 — graph-driven formula (#667), tea CLI integration (#666)
+- Exec agent (#699) — interactive assistant via Matrix
+- Rent-a-human (#679) — formula-dispatchable human action drafts
+- Tech-debt queue cleared (~30 items)
+- Skill package initiative started (#710-#715) from research (#709)
 
 ### Patterns
-- **Predictor over-signals on transient ops issues**: 4/6 predictions this run were orphaned tmux sessions or crashed reviews — things the supervisor handles automatically. Expected to continue until predictor learns to filter supervisor-handled issues.
-- **Label loss on issue creation**: The 3 Adoption issues created last run had no labels when checked this run. Root cause unknown — could be a silent API failure in the planner's issue creation, or labels removed by another process. Watch for recurrence.
-- **Long tech-debt backlog blocks features**: ~20 small backlog items (tech-debt, bug fixes) will be processed before Adoption features due to sequential pipeline and lower issue numbers. Not a problem per se — maintains factory health — but means Adoption work won't start for weeks unless manually prioritized.
-- **needs_human is a silent pipeline killer**: When a dev-agent writes PHASE:needs_human and no human responds, the pipeline stalls silently. Supervisor doesn't escalate. Filed #465 to fix.
+- **Label loss resolved**: #535 fixed the recurring label-loss pattern. Labels now persist reliably.
+- **Predictor signal quality improved**: Later runs show 100% substantive predictions. Over-signaling on transient ops issues has stopped.
+- **Human bottleneck is real**: #466 escalated 2026-03-23, still no response after 3 days. When the factory needs human input and doesn't get it, work halts on that branch entirely.
+- **Factory throughput is extreme when unblocked**: 50+ issues cleared in ~5 days (2026-03-20 to 2026-03-25). Pipeline processes ~10 issues/day when backlog is stocked.
+- **Duplicate issues from parallel creation**: #710/#714 and #711/#715 are duplicates — likely created in separate exec/research sessions. Gardener should catch these.
+- **prediction/backlog migration**: All 4 legacy prediction/backlog items dismissed and closed in run 6. prediction/dismissed label created.
 
 ### Strategic direction
-- Adoption remains the leverage multiplier. All 4 Adoption issues are now in backlog: #393 (init) → #394 (docs) → #395 (dashboard), plus #466 (example project, depends on #393).
-- The critical path is: #393 (init) must land first — docs and example project both reference it.
-- #465 (supervisor needs_human escalation) is operational leverage — prevents the kind of silent stall observed via #446.
+- Ship milestone is the next frontier. Adoption is blocked only on #466 (human decision).
+- Skill package distribution (#710→#711→#712) is the immediate pipeline work — packaging disinto for external discovery.
+- Observable addressables (#718) bridges Fold 2 → Fold 3 — core vision item.
+- The factory has the exec agent (#699) and rent-a-human (#679) — two vision capabilities now live.
+- VISION.md updated with factory primitives (resources, addressables, observables) — formalizes the framework.
 
 ### Watch list
-- Label persistence: verify #393/#394/#395 retain their backlog labels next run
-- Tech-debt throughput: how fast is the dev-agent clearing the backlog queue?
-- #357 (in-progress): action-agent runtime isolation — track completion
-- #448 (prediction/backlog): disk at 75%, trend improving
-- #446 (prediction/backlog): harb needs_human pattern — is #465 picked up?
+- #466: human response overdue (3 days) — will it ever be unblocked?
+- #710-#712: skill package pipeline — first new work direction since Adoption
+- #714/#715: duplicate cleanup by gardener
+- prediction/backlog label: should be deleted per #686, still exists
+- Ship milestone gaps: deploy profiles, assumptions register, vault-gated folds — not yet filed

planner/journal/2026-03-26.md

@@ -0,0 +1,54 @@
+# Planner run — 2026-03-26 07:15 UTC
+
+## Predictions triaged
+- #644: DISMISS — disk P1 handled by supervisor reactive cleanup, no persistent issue
+- #580: DISMISS — Caddy CVEs don't apply to static site (no FastCGI/PHP)
+- #529: DISMISS — swap stable at 57%, supervisor monitors, not trending worse
+- #446: DISMISS — root cause fixed by #465/#510 escalation path improvements
+All 4 were prediction/backlog → migrated to prediction/dismissed per #686 policy. Created prediction/dismissed label (was missing).
+
+## Prerequisite tree updates
+- Resolved: #660 (Forgejo reachability), #661 (Woodpecker CI wiring), #668 (init smoke test), #663 (guard logging), #664 (stale phase cleanup) — all closed
+- Objectives completed: bootstrap (#393) now FULLY DONE (all prereqs resolved), factory operational reliability DONE
+- New objectives added: exec agent (#699) DONE, rent-a-human (#679) DONE, skill package distribution (#710-#712), observable addressables (#718)
+- Discovered: #710-#715 skill package initiative (created since last run), with #714/#715 as duplicates of #710/#711
+
+## Top 5 constraints
+1. #466 — example project — blocks Adoption completion — ESCALATED 3 days, no human response
+2. #710 — skill package creation — enables distribution — in backlog with priority
+3. #718 — observable addressables — Ship milestone bridge — filed this run
+4. #714/#715 — duplicate issues — pending gardener cleanup
+5. prediction/backlog label — should be deleted per #686 — needs admin action
+
+## Stuck issues detected
+- #466: ESCALATED (since 2026-03-23, 3 days) — no human response. Dev-agent bounced as too large, gardener escalated for approach decision. Not re-promoting — already has priority label.
+
+## Issues created
+- #718: feat: observable addressables — engagement measurement for deployed artifacts — Ship milestone, Fold 2→3 bridge
+
+## Priority label changes
+- Added priority: #710 (next ready pipeline work)
+- Kept priority: #466 (still #1 constraint, escalated)
+- No priority removed
+
+## Label changes
+- #710, #711, #712, #713: added backlog (were unlabeled, invisible to pipeline)
+- #644, #580, #529, #446: relabeled from prediction/backlog to prediction/dismissed, closed
+- Created prediction/dismissed label (id: 1335444) — missing despite #686 implementation
+
+## Observations
+- Explosive progress continues: ~30 issues closed since last run (2026-03-25). Bootstrap fully hardened, init smoke test passing, exec agent deployed, rent-a-human implemented.
+- Factory nearly idle: no backlog items existed until this run labeled #710-#713. The skill package chain is the only ready work.
+- Skill package initiative (#710-#715) appeared since last run — created from #709 research. Two parallel tracks with duplicates (#710/#714, #711/#715). Preferred #710 chain, flagged duplicates for gardener.
+- Adoption milestone 4/5 complete. #466 stuck 3 days on human decision. All technical prerequisites resolved. The human bottleneck is real.
+- Ship milestone entering scope: #679 (rent-a-human) and #699 (exec agent) already done. #718 (observable addressables) filed. Deploy profiles and assumptions register remain untracked.
+- VISION.md updated this cycle (3c97ddb) — factory primitives (resources, addressables, observables) now formally defined. Tree reflects this.
+- RESOURCES.md unchanged. Vault empty (no procurement requests).
+- Graph report clean: no cycles, no bottlenecks. Orphan issues are all closed bug fixes — expected.
+
+## Deferred (in tree, not filed)
+- Ship: deploy profiles per artifact type — premature until skill package or example project demonstrates need
+- Ship: assumptions register — needs design decision on format
+- Ship: vault-gated fold transitions — vault infrastructure exists, fold logic not yet designed
+- Scale: plugin system, community formulas, hosted option — premature without users
+- Vision items: #1 (halt/resume), #2 (self-tuning), #4 (multi-VPS) — far future

planner/prerequisite-tree.md

@@ -1,5 +1,5 @@
 # Prerequisite Tree
-<!-- Last updated: 2026-03-25 -->
+<!-- Last updated: 2026-03-26 -->
 
 ## Objective: One-command bootstrap — `disinto init` (#393)
 - [x] Core agent loop stable (Foundation)
@@ -8,10 +8,10 @@
 - [x] Bundled dust cleanup — set-euo-pipefail (#516)
 - [x] Agent-session.sh pre-register worktree trust (#514)
 - [x] Bootstrap hardening — Forgejo INSTALL_LOCK (#634), su-exec (#635), admin user (#636), DNS (#637), crontab (#638), auth (#652), remote target (#653), token creation (#658)
-- [ ] Agents container reaches Forgejo — env.sh override (#660) — in-progress
-- [ ] Woodpecker CI wiring during init (#661) — in backlog
-- [ ] End-to-end init smoke test (#668) — in backlog
-Status: DONE (code merged) — hardening fixes landing, smoke test pending
+- [x] Agents container reaches Forgejo — env.sh override (#660)
+- [x] Woodpecker CI wiring during init (#661)
+- [x] End-to-end init smoke test (#668)
+Status: DONE — all prerequisites resolved, init fully functional
 
 ## Objective: Documentation site with quickstart (#394)
 - [x] disinto init working (#393)
@@ -24,8 +24,8 @@ Status: DONE — #395 closed
 
 ## Objective: Example project demonstrating full lifecycle (#466)
 - [x] disinto init working (#393)
-- [ ] Human decision on implementation approach (external repo vs local demo) ⚠ escalated — awaiting human decision
-Status: BLOCKED — bounced by dev-agent (too large), escalated by gardener (2026-03-23), awaiting human decision
+- [ ] Human decision on implementation approach (external repo vs local demo) ⚠ escalated — awaiting human decision (since 2026-03-23)
+Status: BLOCKED — bounced by dev-agent (too large), escalated by gardener, 3 days without human response
 
 ## Objective: Landing page communicating value proposition (#534)
 - [x] disinto init working (#393)
@@ -47,6 +47,31 @@ Status: DONE — #510 closed
 Status: DONE — #504 closed
 
 ## Objective: Factory operational reliability
-- [ ] check_active guard logs when skipping (#663) — in backlog
-- [ ] Supervisor cleans stale PHASE:escalate files (#664) — in backlog
-Status: BLOCKED — 2 prerequisites unresolved
+- [x] check_active guard logs when skipping (#663)
+- [x] Supervisor cleans stale PHASE:escalate files (#664)
+Status: DONE — both fixes merged
+
+## Objective: Exec agent — interactive executive assistant (#699)
+- [x] Matrix bot infrastructure
+- [x] CHARACTER.md personality definition
+- [x] exec-session.sh implementation
+Status: DONE — #699 closed
+
+## Objective: Rent-a-human — formula-dispatchable human action drafts (#679)
+- [x] Formula infrastructure (run-rent-a-human.toml)
+- [x] Vault gating for human actions
+Status: DONE — #679 closed
+
+## Objective: Skill package distribution (#710 → #711 → #712)
+- [ ] Create disinto skill package — SKILL.md + helper scripts (#710) — in backlog, priority
+- [ ] Publish to ClawHub registry (#711) — in backlog, depends on #710
+- [ ] Submit to secondary registries (#712) — in backlog, depends on #711
+- [ ] Evaluate MCP server wrapper (#713) — in backlog, independent
+- Note: #714, #715 flagged as duplicates of #710, #711 — pending gardener cleanup
+Status: READY — no blocking prerequisites
+
+## Objective: Observable addressables — engagement measurement (#718)
+- [ ] Lightweight analytics on disinto.ai (#718) — in backlog
+- [ ] Deploy formula verifies measurement is live
+- [ ] Planner consumes engagement data
+Status: READY — Ship milestone, Fold 2 → Fold 3 bridge